insurance-canada.ca - Where Insurance & Technology Meet

AI-to-AI Claims Settlement: Putting Claims Technology in Consumers’ Hands

By Joshua Schwadron, Founder & CEO, Mighty —

The insurance industry is already using AI in claims. Personal injury lawyers are using AI in claims too. The real shift now is that accident victims can use AI too after an accident, and that changes what reaches the insurer.

At Mighty, we think AI-to-AI settlement won’t be a consumer’s AI haggling with an insurer’s AI. The offer is driven by the file, not the negotiation, and valuing the claim stays with the insurer. So Mighty doesn’t estimate what a claim is worth, and it doesn’t argue with the insurer. It uses AI to build the case file and get the insurer’s best offer.

This isn’t a novelty. It’s the direction claims are headed: the injured person’s AI builds the file, the insurer’s AI evaluates it, and the person decides what to do with the offer. The advice that follows is simple. For most claims, get the insurer’s best offer first. Then hire a lawyer only if one can improve on it.

The hidden problem: AI made law firms faster, not consumers better off

Over the last decade, legal tech, and now AI, has been built mainly for personal injury law firms. The tools are real: automation for intake, records, demand letters, case summaries, negotiation workflows. But the economics didn’t change. A lawyer’s fee is still usually about a third of the settlement, and most people agree to it in the first days after an accident, before anyone knows what the insurer would offer.

So the consumer sees a weird outcome:

  • AI sped up the work,
  • but the consumer still pays the same share of the settlement.

That’s the core reason Mighty exists: to put claims technology in the hands of the person who actually got hurt, and make it free.

The consumer’s two bad choices (until now)

In the U.S., most auto injury claims settle before litigation. Most of the work is gathering records and bills and sending them to the insurer. Historically, consumers had two bad options:

  • Negotiate alone against a repeat-player insurer with professional playbooks and tooling, or
  • Hire a PI lawyer immediately and give up about a third of the settlement, even when the claim never needed legal work.

Mighty gives consumers a new, third option: a free way to build their case file and get the insurer’s best offer before deciding whether a lawyer is worth it.

What Mighty does 

Mighty is a technology company, not a law firm. It’s free, it works on injury claims such as car, truck, bus and motorcycle crashes, and it’s currently only available in the United States.

Here is how Mighty works for accident victims:

  1. You tell our AI what happened: the accident and the injuries.
  2. We gather the records: the police report, medical records and bills, uploaded by you or requested with your permission.
  3. We build the case file, including anything that hurts the claim.
  4. The case file goes to the at-fault driver’s insurer with a request for its best offer. There’s no number in it and no counteroffer. If the offer misses something, the record that shows it goes in, with a request for an updated offer.
  5. If you accept the offer, you keep all of it.
  6. If you want to see whether a lawyer can improve on it, vetted lawyers from our network can ask to represent you. You choose whether to hire one, and they’re paid only on what they add above that offer.

If an accident victim already has an offer from an insurer, Mighty shows them what it’s built on and what isn’t counted yet. Whether to accept it is their call. Mighty recommends a lawyer sooner only when this path can’t work: a filing deadline too close for an offer, a lawsuit already running against them, or an offer at the at-fault driver’s policy limits.

Why AI-to-AI settlement is the future

This becomes the default because both sides have incentives.

For consumers:

  • They get clarity and a real offer without paying anyone.
  • They avoid giving away about a third of their recovery before anyone knows what the claim is worth.

For insurers:

  • Case files arrive organized, with every fact tied to its source and nothing about the claim held back.
  • Straightforward claims can resolve faster, with fewer touches.
  • Fewer claimants feel forced into hiring a lawyer just to get through the claim.
  • Mighty doesn’t change how insurers handle claims, and it isn’t legal representation.
  • Our incentives don’t push anyone away from a settlement.

We’re on the injured person’s side, always. That happens to be good for insurers too: a good offer up front is in the insurer’s own interest, because it leaves a lawyer little to add. More for insurers is at mighty.com/insurers.

The end state is clear to us: most claims resolve on a complete file and a real offer, and lawyers spend their time where there’s legal work to do.

The combination that matters

There are products that help with pieces of this: valuation tools, intake tools, workflow tools for lawyers, portals, and marketplaces. But the combination that matters is:

  • direct-to-consumer,
  • free, and
  • AI building the case file through to the insurer’s best offer (not just a calculator, not just a document generator).

That is what Mighty is doing today. A person can use it start to finish and never share their case with a lawyer at all.

What the industry should watch next

If you lead claims at an insurer, or you’re a broker or insurtech leader, the important questions aren’t philosophical. They’re operational:

  • What happens to cycle time when case files arrive cleaner and more standardized?
  • What happens to representation rates when consumers have a real offer before they decide about a lawyer?
  • What does a fair resolution look like when a lawyer’s fee comes only from what they add above the insurer’s offer?

AI is already in claims. The next chapter is who gets access to it. We think the consumer should.

About Mighty

Mighty is where an injury claim starts. It’s a New York-based technology company, not a law firm. Mighty uses AI to build the case file and get the insurer’s best offer, free, for people hurt in car, truck, bus and motorcycle crashes in the U.S. Then they decide: keep it, or see if a lawyer can improve on it. For more information, visit www.mighty.com.

This article was originally posted March 4, 2026. It was revised November 13, 2026.

Source: Mighty